Atopy and acquired immune deficiency - issues of control of two extremes of a spectrum of paediatric respiratory disorders with an immunological basis

Abstract

Twenty publications are submitted. All deal with the issues of control of two ends of the spectrum of immune-mediated respiratory disorders in children, namely atopic (asthma and allergic rhinitis) and HIV-related lung disease. This submission summarises the research by the author into this spectrum of lung diseases of children in South Africa, highlighting the diversity of conditions that are not only clinically important, but also common. Understanding of all conditions is required to improve the health of children in this region. Management of chronic conditions requires two major end points - adequate and timely diagnosis and - management to control the condition. The author has a passion for improving the quality of life of children and firmly believes that the research findings will, and have, led to transformation in management of both these common disorders. This document follows the progression of the authors research work and highlights how interesting and important is the scope of two disorders which could be thought to have a central origin, namely in the T-cell. T-cells form the basis of cellular immunity and an excess of T-helper 2 cell activity promotes atopy, whilst the human immunodeficiency (HI) virus infects T-helper cells and promotes cellular immune deficiency and its attendant clinical disorders. The author’s research work is not based on the immunological basis of these conditions but does deal with the clinical implications and especially aspects relating to control of these two extremes of a clinical spectrum of disorders. To take the clarity of two diseases at the end of a spectrum to its natural conclusion these extremes are defined in aetiology or pathophysiological differences (excess versus suppression of the immune system), occurring in the affluent and poor alike versus just the poor, control being required to improve quality of life versus to save lives and finally that management requires anti-inflammatory therapy versus antibiotic and anti-infective therapy. For the eight publications based on atopic respiratory disease in children the themes are firstly that children with asthma and chronic rhinitis are diagnosed late, that most individuals with these conditions are not well controlled and finally that the reasons for lack of control are becoming obvious. For the first time, the significant lack of asthma and allergic rhinitis control in South Africa is documented. These studies suggest that, like surveys from the rest of the world, asthma control is seriously under-estimated and neglected in all asthmatics in South Africa, in both the privileged and the under-privileged. The research also defines reasons for poor asthma and allergic rhinitis control in this region. As in many studies published from around the world it is now evident that poor asthma and allergic rhinitis control cannot be blamed on any one source. A multitude of reasons underlie this phenomenon and each of the subsequent papers in this section illustrates attempts at defining these principles. The three most important reasons for poor control are probably that most asthmatics are managed in the wrong hands (by doctors who don’t understand adequate control and who aren’t empowered to use the correct therapy), that control may actually be a pipe dream and practically difficult to do or even impossible to achieve and lastly that the allergic basis of asthma is over emphasised and may not in fact determine all asthma. The subsequent papers summarise research work in the field of HV infection in children and exposes the opposite end of a spectrum of Paediatric respiratory disease and highlight research into the conditions common in HIV-infected children. Eleven papers are presented. For the diseases associated with the HI virus the major complications of inadequate diagnosis and prevention in children are acute pneumonia (especially severe pneumonia) and bronchiectasis. Bronchiolitis is not common in HIV infected children, despite epidemics of this condition in non-infected children. Passive smoking does not aggrevate or worsen disease progression in children. The complications of HIV related diseases in children require the same principles of adequate diagnosis and control as would apply to the chronic atopic conditions. Once the author delved into the disorders at the other end of the clinical spectrum, namely those associated with immune deficiency secondary to HIVinfection he faced the question of a possible relationship between the conditions. One submission explores that relationship. This research has a unique perspective, conferred by the fact that these two conditions do not occur to the same extent anywhere else in the world. Atopic respiratory conditions and HIV-related lung diseases occur side by side in abundance in this region. This perspective has created a clarity for research to address the two most important aims in clinical medicine, namely to diagnose correctly and then to manage the condition so that control is achieved. These must be universal principles of the successful practice of medicine.